Ukraine calls strategic pause in Tymoshenko trial

Print version
Sept. 30, 2011, 8:03 p.m. | Politics — by Reuters


The trial of Ukrainian ex-prime minister Yulia Tymoshenko, on a charge of abuse of office, was adjourned on Friday for 11 days to give the political leadership time to ponder its next move in the face of fierce criticism from the West. Judge Rodion Kireyev said the trial of the 50-year-old opposition leader would be paused until Oct. 11 at the earliest, and was expected to announce his verdict soon after it resumed.

State prosecutors have asked for a seven-year jail sentence to be passed on the charismatic politician who they allege exceeded her powers as prime minister by forcing through a 2009 gas deal with Russia to the detriment of Ukraine.

She denies this and says the trial is a vendetta against her by her arch-rival, President Viktor Yanukovich.

Kireyev gave no specific reason for the adjournment. He said the court would re-convene again "round about" Oct. 11.

But political commentators said it was clearly designed to give Yanukovich and his ruling circle a breathing space in which to consider their options following pressure from the European Union and the United States over the case.

The EU, with which Ukraine is negotiating important agreements on association and free trade, has said these will be jeopardised if Tymoshenko is jailed.

It has urged Yanukovich to push through amendments to the criminal law to re-classify the charge against Tymoshenko to allow her to go free and continue as an opposition politician.

"Yanukovich needs these two weeks to make a decision. He is in a difficult situation in that the prosecutor has asked for a seven-year jail sentence on Tymoshenko," said political analyst Viktor Nebozhenko.

"They (the Yanukovich administration) are looking for a solution ... If he (Yanukovich) puts her in jail she will become at a stroke the most famous dissident in Europe, and who needs that?," he said.


EU officials again spelled out the tough message to Yanukovich on Friday at an 'Eastern partnership' summit in neighbouring Poland.

"We have expressed ourselves very clearly to the authorities of Ukraine that the whole EU, and each of us separately, believe the bad treatment of the democratic opposition and the violation of democratic standards ... may overshadow the final stage of the negotiations (on association agreement)," Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk told a Warsaw news conference.

"We expressed our concern about the fate of the former prime minister and we expressed our rejection of a possible selective use of criminal judicial measures against former government members," said European Council president Herman van Rompuy.

In comments to the court before the adjournment, Tymoshenko, who spoke for four hours on Thursday, said: "The sentence which Kireyev will announce will testify to whether Yanukovich wants European integration for Ukraine."

Yanukovich, who narrowly beat Tymoshenko in an election for president in February 2010, denies he is hounding Tymoshenko and says her trial is part of efforts by his leadership to root out corruption.


In an impassioned speech on Thursday, the fiery opposition leader said she was the victim of a "classic lynching trial" which had brought humiliation on the country.

The leadership says Tymoshenko's action in pressuring the state energy firm Naftotgaz into signing a 2009 agreement with the Russian gas giant Gazprom saddled Ukraine with exorbitant prices for gas.

The trial has polarised public opinion in the ex-Soviet republic and led to street demonstrations against Yanukovich.

Tymoshenko, a stylish dresser with a trademark peasant-style hairbraid, is idolised by many older voters, particularly women, in central and eastern Ukraine.

But, although she is a powerful orator and a shrewd political operator, she can be abrasive and is regarded as a divisive figure even by many other opposition figures.

All the same, many commentators say the trial has turned into a public relations disaster for Yanukovich, drawing criticism from the West and resurrecting Tymoshenko as a political force.

Hundreds of Tymoshenko supporters, with riot police stationed nearby, have been camped outside the courtroom throughout the summer in solidarity with her.
The Kyiv Post is hosting comments to foster lively debate. Criticism is fine, but stick to the issues. Comments that include profanity or personal attacks will be removed from the site. If you think that a posted comment violates these standards, please flag it and alert us. We will take steps to block violators.
Anonymous Sept. 30, 2011, 8:34 p.m.    

she is a bandit

{# <-- parent id goes here
Anonymous Sept. 30, 2011, 10:07 p.m.    

But only a very small one, otherwise she would be president now....

{# <-- parent id goes here
Anonymous Sept. 30, 2011, 8:38 p.m.    

Delaying the sentencing of the Tymoshenko for 11 days, just ascertains the fact that Yanukovych has control of what is taking place in regards to the trial. Prior to attending UN General Assembly, the sentencing was delayed because it could have been a very embarrassing situation for Yanukovych while he was at the UN, if a verdict had been announced. His people could not afford for him to face all the condemnation from other leaders and questioning from the Western media. Again, the postponement of the trial was directed from above, and it shows just how much control Yanukovych has over the judicial court system. He continues to maintain that the court system is independent but the actions tell a different story. Now that he is meeting with the EU leadership, he has to avoid the same scenario which, he was facing at UN. It would not surprise me that he discover that the EU leadership was not going to back off from the warnings that they made publicly and privately, in regards to the trial of Tymoshenko. He must have found out that the EU leadership was serious and very concern with what is taking place in Ukraine. Now he has to come back to Ukraine and regroup for the next round, which will determined if Tymoshenko is released or imprison. It is very embarrassing that the Ukrainian leadership has found itself in a difficult situation, when it never had to be this way, but it's not surprising coming from Yanukovych. He cannot comprehend that his actions just keep back firing on him. The hole keeps getting deeper and deeper. He should have already learned his lesson and he is probably getting bad advice from his cronies. Maybe now he can take time and reflect as to what is going on and how stupid he is seen by the public and the international community.

{# <-- parent id goes here
Anonymous Sept. 30, 2011, 9:03 p.m.    

Yhe &quot;bandits&quot; are not in prison but in parliament, the judicial system, and in the leadership.Not to mention the bandit oligarchs who are bleediing Ukraine.

{# <-- parent id goes here
Anonymous Oct. 3, 2011, 2:55 p.m.    

Show me a politician who is not a bandit! Yulia is no better or worse than any of the previous leaders of Ukraina! They are mostly the same, if she goes to prison so should all the others - al have made bad decisions for the country, stolen money from the people and put power in the hands of the oligarths - who truly run the Rada! However, Yanu has shown his colours, and this will not be forgotten - no wonder even the Russian Leadership do not trust him! Dig yourself a hole but don't hide the dirt to fill it in again...

{# <-- parent id goes here


© 1995–2014 Public Media

Web links to Kyiv Post material are allowed provided that they contain a URL hyperlink to the material and a maximum 500-character extract of the story. Otherwise, all materials contained on this site are protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced without the prior written permission of Public Media at
All information of the Interfax-Ukraine news agency placed on this web site is designed for internal use only. Its reproduction or distribution in any form is prohibited without a written permission of Interfax-Ukraine.