One of the most significant problems within the Ukrainian diaspora worldwide, and especially in the US where it matters most, is the lack of political sophistication among organizational members. Intentions are mostly good, but they are rarely informed and aimed so as not to interfere with one's personal life no matter how banal. Internationally, the Ukraine issue has become tangential or marginal, which suggests that it is not a priority. The bottom line is that there is no war strategy.
There are numerous examples for this characterization. A case in point is recognizing that the war in Ukraine is 10 years old and the full-scale atrocities are two years old. Many organizations have spent time and resources organizing events for this occasion. These events have taken a myriad of forms: demonstrations, vigils, conferences and – frankly – I have no idea how to characterize events organized by the Ukrainian Institute of America in New York City. Essentially it was announced almost as an Institute touring exercise.
There was an interesting event which I attended at the Cooper Union Great Hall, historically the site of a speech by President Abraham Lincoln. It had possibilities for strategic success, meaning helping Ukraine because of the venue, sponsorship by relatively important partners including universities, at least one recognizable speaker and the very acute problems facing Ukraine today.
The main speaker was Oleksandra Matviichuk, president of the Center for Civil Liberties and a recent Ukrainian Nobel laureate. Her virtual presentation was eloquent, informative, moving, and emotional. She made a significant observation, albeit erroneous, that in recent history (the last one hundred years) the only case of punishment against an aggressor was through the Nuremberg Tribunal. She suggested the need for a similar tribunal to punish Russia for its war crimes today.
Update on Russia’s ‘Massive’ Overnight Electric Grid Attack
What she failed to mention was the need for victory to enable any existing tribunal to act and implement decisions or verdicts. She did mention support but failed to call specifically for ammunition for Ukraine to achieve that victory. That should have been the focus of her presentation.
There were other speakers and a roundtable discussion which mostly bemoaned how much the Ukrainians have suffered during the war. The moderator did not focus on the strategic immediate needs of Ukraine. Towards the end, she did raise the issue of very little time remaining and the discussants then merely touched upon this important and very complex topic of jurisdiction, criminal intent and evidence involving the United Nations Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide, the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court.
This was an opportunity to help Ukraine in the war. It turned into an academic discussion. Perhaps worse, it gave many in the audience a satisfaction that by attending they had done their part in somehow assisting Ukraine's war effort.
Such events could have an important role in garnering support for Ukraine, particularly in the US, which after all is the strongest military and economic power in the world, but has, and continues to experience, problems with its identity as a foundational NATO member and the leading democracy in the world today to the point that the future of NATO is questioned.
Europeans are considering an alternative European defense structure, relying less and less upon US military capability. The focus has to be on strategic and tangible assistance which is absolutely crucial today.
It should be stressed that Europe's contribution to NATO is increasing annually and about two thirds of NATO members are fulfilling their two percent GDP budgetary commitment. It should also be recognized that only once in its history has Article 5 of the NATO charter been invoked and that was to benefit the US. These facts are anathema to most of the primitives within the Republican party.
Ukraine needs to win the war. That must be the focus. It needs soldiers and ammunition. Lamentations, condemnations, even international Court rulings are all important, but right now Ukraine needs shells, Patriots, Abrams. HIMARS, F-16s. Without victory there will be no punishment for war crimes or genocide. Worse, there may not be a democratic Ukraine in the center of Europe.
That should be the paramount strategic concern for the entire democratic world.
The views expressed are the author’s and not necessarily of Kyiv Post.
You can also highlight the text and press Ctrl + Enter
Comments (3)
The problem with having a war strategy is deriving agreement on the final goal. Or maybe there needs to be a schedule of interconnecting goals. Not all need to be specified now, although there may be strategic goals that are important no matter the final goal. Having a democrat in the White House and a fully democratic Congress after this year's election is an important stand-alone goal which all Ukrainian-Americans must work to deliver
Crucial to any "war strategy" is the failure of the presidential candidate who espouses vitriol against Ukraine and reverence to Putin. American-Ukrainian organizations should stop navel-gazing and implement a plan to "get the vote out" for Joe Biden and democrat Congresspeople. We know what Trump's Ukraine policy will be and we've seen what a Republican House of Representatives has done to the flow of military aid to Ukraine.
There is no more critical mission than to stop Trump from being in the White House. Ukrainian_Americans should identify the states that will determine the Presidency and develop a strategy to "get the Ukrainian vote out" targetting the diaspora and friends of Ukraine (Baltic, Polish etc diaspora). Similarly for Senate candidates.
Simpler should be the targetting House of Representative seats of Trump mouthpieces and Republicans holding marginal seats. Registration tactics need to be developed. Alternatively campaign donations could be directed to appropriate.
American-Ukrainians, please do something. Whether Ukraine wins or loses depends on each one of you, moreso than anybody else in our diaspora. Start strategising now!
candidates.
@Danny Kozak, Well said and great insights!
I figure putinrumps kool-aid drinking cult may horrendously now represent 5-10% of US voters. Another 25-35% are republican voters no matter what candidate is proposed. Party before principle people. Morals don't matter. Trump attempted to overthrow the legally elected government, rape woman, cheat and steal at taxpayer expense, 4091 lawsuits, 91 felonies, 2 impeachments, +30,500 lies told in his last term........ AND THEY DON"T CARE!....Arghhhh! If he's the republican candidate they will vote for him. Moral scum all. They are also unfortunately all active voters and they will reliably show up on Election Day.
If a good chunk of the remaining 65%, who know exactly how evil putinrump is, do not show up it will not bode well for the USA, Ukraine or any other ally. Those in that grouping who do not show up to vote are just as responsible for the impact of a second putinrump presidency as the MRGA cult in my opinion.
There is too much at stake in this next election to not take a moral stand and vote against putinrump. If ever decent Americans are to vote...this is the key election of their life time.
Troll John from Canada, please give us your stupid and idiotic insights.
@Joseph Swanson, Well thanks for the invitation.....at this time of the day though folks would probably get a bigger chuckle out of my 'Sunday Fun" responses to your other MRGA taunts today.
The author makes a good point. The work others do in keeping supporters motivated / track putin crimes / and update on Ukraine's successes is all important. However, I agree that the focus this month needs to be on getting Ukraine the full weapon support it needs ASAP.
That makes it particularly important to continually shame the MRGA folks stalling Ukraine aid in the US House. The EU found its workaround to its MRGA shills (orban, Rico), so right now negative attention has to be focused on putinrump's MRGA minions.
Its time to evict House speaker Mike Johnson and move forward with the current bipartisan package. They've stalled future US aid for 5 months now. They've lost the moral right to make further time consuming politically motivated changes / delays now.
Due entirely to these putin aligned MRGA minions, this has been the least productive congress in USA history. The American taxpayer deserve better. Voters need to know that the parasite sucking the lifeblood out of their nation is putin'rump's MRGA party.