On Monday, June 19, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa celebrated an African mission aimed at brokering peace in Ukraine. He went as far as calling it “historic,” highlighting that it marked a milestone by being the first time for African leaders going on a peace mission beyond the boundaries of their own continent.

Ramaphosa shared his thoughts after returning from discussions held in Kyiv, Ukraine’s capital, and Saint Petersburg, Russia.

According to Ramaphosa, one of the mission’s noteworthy achievements was the positive reception received from both sides, Ukraine and Russia.

The African continent held high hopes for the trip, anticipating that it would contribute to resolving the war that has significantly impacted living standards across Africa. The conflict has led to a scarcity of grain and a sharp increase in global food prices.

Advertisement

However, the glaring reality remains: neither of the warring sides was willing to engage in peace talks without certain preconditions.

Ukraine seeks to restore its borders to the way they were in 1991. This would require Russia to withdraw from all the territories it has forcefully taken from Ukraine over the last 10 years, including the Crimean Peninsula. Yet the Kremlin strongly opposes this demand and is unwilling to comply.

This raises the question of whether the whole endeavor has made any difference or if it was merely a ploy by Ramaphosa to attract attention on the global stage, diverting focus from the mounting problems in South Africa.

Two Years into Russia-Ukraine War, Negotiations a Distant Prospect
Other Topics of Interest

Two Years into Russia-Ukraine War, Negotiations a Distant Prospect

2024 will be another year of war because Ukraine is determined to keep on fighting to recapture territory, while Putin will only be satisfied with Kyiv's full surrender, analysts and diplomats say.

The “staged” missile attack scandal might be the South African peace mission’s main “achievement.”

The African peace mission in Ukraine was marred by a scandal with “a staged missile attack.”   

On Friday, June 16, shortly after the arrival of an African delegation, Kyiv was targeted by a Russian missile attack. However, Vincent Magwenya, the spokesperson for South Africa’s President, denied witnessing any attack and called it deliberate misinformation.

Advertisement

“It’s very strange that we didn’t hear or see an explosion,” he said. “There’s obviously some deliberate misinformation being spread here. People are going on about their day,” he told South African news outlet News 24.

Referring to a short video he posted on Twitter around the time the air alert was in place, he said of the reports of explosions: “From my own experience and those I am travelling with, yes, I am disputing it. Watch the video I shared.

Magwenya’s comments were swiftly taken up by Russian state media as evidence the missile attack was faked.

President Ramaphosa himself, during a press conference after meeting Ukrainian President Zelensky, acknowledged reports of missile strikes, saying that “the launch of missiles today does not deter us and has not stopped our call for de-escalation.

Blurred reality and incomplete neutrality

The neutrality of the African delegation as a whole has been questioned multiple times, particularly South Africa’s stance on Moscow’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine. South Africa had refrained from condemning the invasion and had even deepened its military ties with Russia since the conflict began.

Advertisement

Zelensky argued that condemning Moscow was crucial to send a clear message to the Russian people, making them aware of their president’s actions leading to their international isolation.

During the press conference, President Ramaphosa reiterated some of the narratives allegedly found in Russian propaganda. He expressed respect for the people of Ukraine but also emphasized the importance of a sense of security for “all countries involved” as the basis for any peace agreement.

 

“There are offensives on both sides, and we are saying there must be de-escalation as both countries proceed on the road to peace.”

Zelensky said that he would not allow himself to be forced into any negotiations unless Russia withdrew its forces from Ukrainian territory.

Following the press conference, Zelensky criticized the rhetoric of African leaders who call Russia’s war against Ukraine a “conflict” or “crisis.” He emphasised that the ongoing “conflict” was not merely a crisis but a full-fledged war, resulting in constant rocket attacks, civilian casualties, and ecocide.

“Some of my colleagues continue to call this war a crisis. And even now, publicly, they continue to do so. This is their right to choose, but it shows that we have different assessments of the situation,” Ukraine’s President said.

Advertisement

Zelensky also stressed that the problems with grain in Africa were not the result of a “crisis,” but the fact that Russia single-handedly blocked Ukrainian ports.

While the efforts of Ramaphosa’s delegation failed to achieve any of the peace mission aims, he maintains that they have at least created an opportunity for future dialogue.

It is plausible that, amidst domestic challenges such as deteriorating infrastructure and rising dissatisfaction with his administration, Ramaphosa sought to highlight a diplomatic victory on the global platform.

Regrettably for him, this particular peace mission has not yielded any triumph.

To suggest a correction or clarification, write to us here
You can also highlight the text and press Ctrl + Enter

Comments (9)

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
Joseph Swanson
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

It is sad that the global South Nations, especially Africa forget how the russians also hurted their ancestors.In 1889 russia laid claims to the village of Sagallo in present-day Djibouti.
By the beginning of the 20th Century around 25, 000 russian settlers had established themselves in South Africa. Yes, settlers  who stole black land AND displaced black South Africans! The russians were amongst the strongest supporters of the Boer Republics in the Boer War. The largest international solidarity groups raising money, material aid, medical support detachments and fighters for the Boer army were in russia and Holland and these included the royal families. The russians were totally infatuated with the Boers and admired their way of life. russian immigrants joined special detachments of russian fighters to aid the Boer War effort.

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
Neutral observer
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

Erdogan is in the same league as these so called leaders of African States. Duingenous and entirely self serving. Turkey should be suspended from NATO for ineffective execution of sanctions on Russia. Particularly for allowing leakage of electronic Como ents used in missiles to attack the innocent people of Ukraine.

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
Hugh M.
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

Fluff Diplomacy

(full of air without substance)

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
Hugh M.
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

Trying to look relevant & ending up even more irrelevant.
Except for their own country's news, where they already control the news.

What do we call it in the U.S?:

"Headlines" for newspapers

"Sound Bites" for the TV or radio

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
William Spillman
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

The 'African' initiative that was in Putin's corner to begin with, didn't achieve anything. Now the African 'leaders' who attended can pretend that they tried to do something but the wicked Ukrainians refused to accept Putin's requirement of total surrender. No wonder Africa continues to be a 3rd world backwater, enslaved to China and Russia. There is no morality or ethics involved, only power politics. The 'leaders' of African countries are venal and corrupt. Fix your own problems, Africans, before you preach to others to do what you will not do. The African 'leaders' involved in this debacle have only debased themselves. They seem small and getting smaller on the world stage. Africa fails once again. After finally throwing off the yoke of colonialism, African countries seem to want to kiss the boots of Russian and Chinese hegemony. What fools, and what disregard for all the African patriots that died to set their countries free.

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
Paolo
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

It's plain to see who supports ukraine and who supports Russian anything else is just noise..

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
I support
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

Historically worthless

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
Joseph Swanson
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

communists & their sympathizers & supporters will always play these types of word games...in this case calling a failed peace / diplomatic mission as "historic." There was nothing positive about their attempt.

Paolo
This comment contains spoilers. Click here if you want to read.

@Joseph Swanson, correct and nobody can play the game better than Erdoğan.
They don't care about human suffering, they just see a business opportunity.
They're happy to make the right noises now and again just as long as the money and cheap russian oil keeps flowing.

https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png
https://www.kyivpost.com/assets/images/author.png