A summit between European, Latin American and Caribbean leaders on Tuesday highlighted their differences over how to tackle Russia’s war in Ukraine.
As leaders from the EU and the Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC) met for a second day, diplomats were struggling to agree the language of a final communique.
A handful of Latin American countries -- diplomats cited Nicaragua, Cuba and Venezuela as the most adamant -- were opposed to agreeing a text holding Moscow responsible for the conflict.
Other leaders from the region were ready to sign up in support of Ukraine’s sovereignty, but put more emphasis on the need for a negotiated peace, rather than a victory for Kyiv, in their their public declaration.
Leaders arriving for the talks expressed confidence that a text would be agreed, but some Europeans expressed frustration with the holdouts’ views on the conflict.
“It would be a shame that we are not able to say that there is Russian aggression in Ukraine,” said Luxembourg’s Prime Minister Xavier Bettel.
“It’s a fact, and I’m not here to rewrite history”.
Latin American leaders came to the summit hoping to make progress unblocking a stalled EU trade deal, and some Caribbeans wanted to discuss reparations for European colonialism and slavery.
They have expressed some frustration with Europe’s insistence on the importance of the war in Ukraine, but officials still hoped to be able to release a final text.
ISW Russian Offensive Campaign Assessment, May 3, 2024
Irish leader Leo Varadkar said talks had gone late into the night on Monday and that the debate was a valid one, even if the conclusion should be clear.
- Forgotten wars? -
“A lot of countries will point out that there are other conflicts in the world, and I hear that,” he told reporters.
“And they will say that other conflicts in the world perhaps haven’t got the same amount of attention as Ukraine.”
In the opening session on Monday, CELAC president Prime Prime Minister Ralph Gonsalves of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, cited the crisis in Haiti, the Palestinian struggle for statehood and various wars in Africa as deserving of European attention.
And he warned that “sanctions and blockades” triggered by the war in Ukraine would only serve “to penalise the most vulnerable populations.
As the leaders met in Brussels, Russia refused to extend a deal to allow Ukrainian grain exports through the Black Sea, drawing a warning from the UN that millions of the world’s poorest would “pay the price”.
“There are points that were validly made,” Varadkar conceded.
“But two wrongs don’t make a right. What Russia is doing in Ukraine is wrong and it’s really important that we’re clear about that here.”
Poland’s Mateusz Morawiecki was more blunt, arguing that countries that once suffered from European colonialism should recognise that Russia is now the imperialist threat.
“Here in Europe it’s hard to imagine, but in Latin America, Russia is presented as a peaceful country that has been attacked by NATO,” he said.
“I would say that by its aggressive policy, Russia is pursuing a colonialist policy, is a colonial empire”.
Not all the Latin American countries were opposed to a tough statement on Russia.
Alberto van Klaveren, Chile’s foreign minister, said: “We are very surprised there are members of our group which oppose any resolution concerning the war in Ukraine.
“We think it’s a war of aggression. That’s the position of Chile.”
You can also highlight the text and press Ctrl + Enter
Comments (2)
It is sad that the global South Nations, especially Africa forget how the russians also hurted their ancestors.In 1889 russia laid claims to the village of Sagallo in present-day Djibouti.
By the beginning of the 20th Century around 25, 000 russian settlers had established themselves in South Africa. Yes, settlers who stole black land AND displaced black South Africans! The russians were amongst the strongest supporters of the Boer Republics in the Boer War. The largest international solidarity groups raising money, material aid, medical support detachments and fighters for the Boer army were in russia and Holland and these included the royal families. The russians were totally infatuated with the Boers and admired their way of life. russian immigrants joined special detachments of russian fighters to aid the Boer War effort.
Nicaragua, Cuba and Venezuela...all communist, who support communist russia. No surprise.
As usual, one can count on only deliberate indifference from the third world.